Panini outstanding redemption replacement request... how did i do?

J

JonX

Verified Trader,
Joined
Apr 2, 2004
Messages
1,627
Reaction score
0
Location
Montréal, QC
my main pc is jarred tinordi and have been waiting on a lot of his panini auto for a very long time... looks like hell never sign his cards (he did sign his national treasures cards) so decided to ask for replacements. i ask for habs cards in return lmk how i did, i diddnt received the cafrds yet but they updated my resquest with the cards i will receive by fedex

i exchanged

these are all Jarred tinordi cards:

Dominion rpa /299
dominion rpa gold /50
dominion auto patch /99
ice level jersey /50
ice level prime /10
ice level patch /5

crown royale silhouette /99

from totally certified:
rookie jersey auto
platinum red jersey auto /50
platinum blue prime auto /25
platinum Mirror blue prime /10
patinum gold patch auto /10
platinum Mirror gold patch auto /5

also excehange a calvin pacikard dominion auto patch /99
and a jt miller anthologydual prime jersey auto /50

heres what im supposed to get in exchange

pk subban zenith rookie auto /199
christian thomas totally certified platinum gold patch auto /10
Brendan gallagher totally certified slidshow auto /20
Brendan gallagher national treasures triple mem auto
gabriel dumont 12/13 panini prime rookies jumbo patch auto /5
gabriel dumont 12/13 panini prime rookies black auto /3
jarred tinordi totally certified rookie slideshow auto /10 (one fo his rare that he did sign)
pk subban 10/11 contenders rookie ticket auto
yvan cournoyer national tresures greatest signatures auto /25
jean beliveau 11/12 limited select signatures auto /99
bob gainey national tresures tresured trophies auto /25
brian gionta panini prime genuine marks lett patch auto /6

i think these are fair replacements. of course if tinordi does ever return his cards ill have to acquire them all over again. but panini might run out of hockey stock to replace their redemption so decided to take a chance
 
Last edited:
I figure that's a pretty solid exchange.

I like Tinner but it's getting pretty close to the make-or-break point for him in his development. Beaulieu leap-frogged him last year and I daresay that Pateryn has too.

So you came away with two hard-signed Subban RC's, a couple nice Gallaghers, and autos of Beliveau, Cournoyer, Gainey, plus a sweet Gionta. All told, that's a positive...and it's always nice to get cards that exist as opposed to ones that may never exist.
 
I would never argue with a Beliveau auto. Congrats on the replacements. I asked for mine last week, hopefully they are as good as yours.
 
Last edited:
RGM81 said:
I figure that's a pretty solid exchange.

I like Tinner but it's getting pretty close to the make-or-break point for him in his development. Beaulieu leap-frogged him last year and I daresay that Pateryn has too.

So you came away with two hard-signed Subban RC's, a couple nice Gallaghers, and autos of Beliveau, Cournoyer, Gainey, plus a sweet Gionta. All told, that's a positive...and it's always nice to get cards that exist as opposed to ones that may never exist.
Click to expand...

Totally agree with this post 100%. :dance:
 
3 HOF autos and a few of a couple of very popular Habs for low numbered cards of a prospect that is getting lost in the wash of players within the organization. I know he's your guy and that's who you collect, but that's a really solid exchange for sure.
 
RGM81 said:
I figure that's a pretty solid exchange.

I like Tinner but it's getting pretty close to the make-or-break point for him in his development. Beaulieu leap-frogged him last year and I daresay that Pateryn has too.

So you came away with two hard-signed Subban RC's, a couple nice Gallaghers, and autos of Beliveau, Cournoyer, Gainey, plus a sweet Gionta. All told, that's a positive...and it's always nice to get cards that exist as opposed to ones that may never exist.
Click to expand...

Tinordi's type of play takes time to develop. He'll be a regular in the lineup soon. Plus he suffered a setback with his injury.
 
Burner said:
Tinordi's type of play takes time to develop. He'll be a regular in the lineup soon. Plus he suffered a setback with his injury.
Click to expand...

Define "soon" and at whose expense?

Barring injuries/trades I don't see him in the lineup this season, certainly not as a regular. Next year, with Gilbert possibly gone, sure it's possible.

He's 23 now and coming into the final year of his entry-level deal so the Habs are going to have to decide whether or not his services will be retained. If they are, he's going to be on a very cheap contract since he has no bargaining power.

I like the kid, don't get me wrong, and for his sake I hope he has an amazing camp and forces Bergevin's hand to make a deal to fit him in the lineup. But I dunno if that's how it will play out.
 
RGM81 said:
Define "soon" and at whose expense?

Barring injuries/trades I don't see him in the lineup this season, certainly not as a regular. Next year, with Gilbert possibly gone, sure it's possible.

He's 23 now and coming into the final year of his entry-level deal so the Habs are going to have to decide whether or not his services will be retained. If they are, he's going to be on a very cheap contract since he has no bargaining power.

I like the kid, don't get me wrong, and for his sake I hope he has an amazing camp and forces Bergevin's hand to make a deal to fit him in the lineup. But I dunno if that's how it will play out.
Click to expand...

if he has a strong camp in think bergevin will try to deal away emelin.


like others said im happy with the replacements, its way better than getting no cards at all, and tinordi does return his cards i can always buy them back or trade them
 

Latest posts

Forum statistics

Threads
390,143
Messages
2,238,829
Members
4,169
Latest member
Misso
Back
Top