2004 SP Authentic Designs - Horrible

ajbry

Registered Trader
Joined
Aug 9, 2003
Messages
1,367
Reaction score
0
Location
Cape Cod, MA
Is it just me, or do the 2004 SP Authentic designs leave a lot to be desired?

Base Design
c6_1_b.JPG


Not too bad, no major problems.

Rookie Autographed Patches
9b_1.JPG


Well, when SPA released, the season was 14 weeks in. Why are the photos on these cards being used from the rookie photo shoot? The design is lame, no cropping to make the background look decent, and the flow is pathetic. The whole card has a lame design, and the text of the player's name carries over into the picture.

Scripts for Success Autographs
4d_1.JPG


Not all of the players in this set are rookies, but a college jersey? Boring design with boring text. The only good thing is that the autograph is actually on the card itself.

Base Rookie Autographs
e3_1_b.JPG


Still plenty of college jerseys, as well as practice jerseys. Why aren't there any actual game photos? If the player has not even been on the sidelines, warming up during a game for a photo opportunity, should they even be in the set to begin with?

Sign of the Times
06_1_b.JPG


An incredibly boring design. No cropping, just a tiny head shot of the player, with tons of unused space, and just a lackluster overall look.


If I seem critical, it's only because UD didn't take the time to make one of the most highly anticipated products of the year worthwhile. Laziness shouldn't be an option.
 
And it's so unlike UD to be half assed about their product :P

You and I should be designing stuff for these companies Aj
 
AJ could you do anything like the "NFL ICONS" section from Madden 05?
All you would do is put a cut out photo of the player in front of the team logo.

Mike
 
The Rookie Auto Patch design is horrible. The auto's and jersey's are just jammed into the lower left of the card and the names carrying over onto the pictures doesn't look too good either.
 
I'm prety much reversed on this one - I hate the base design, but the AUTO JSY RC's are the nice, definitely better than last year's. They have the feel of the pre-millenium SP hockey cards.

But I do agree that the SOTT set is terrible (they had it perfect in 2002).
 
i am not a football fan but i'll give my 34 cents. The regular auto set looks to much like pacific or somehtig like not much design into it at all. i like the signs of the success the best i think the card looks half descent.
 

Forum statistics

Threads
389,442
Messages
2,232,607
Members
4,144
Latest member
Collector Driven
Back
Top