As a BMP'er I would like to reply to this thread to explain some of the happenings
I've had hit and misses there, but for the most part, it's worked out well for me.
Misses = occasionally the bigger storefronts or those who do eBay based off Beckett listing's will have sold something before the Beckett order goes thru.
This is probably my biggest issue. I will get an order on Ebay or vice versa and I will not have a chance to remove it from the other site before it sells. I try to replace the card either way, but sometimes it is not easy to do and then I have to refund the money. This happens very rarely, but this is the biggest issue that I have.
Will they usually combine shipping? I'm trying to find shipping prices but some aren't showing. Just don't want to buy and have $5 shipping on $1 cards
What I suggest doing (and this is how I shop the BMP) is that if I find a card that I need, AND there are a significant quantity listed on the site, I put one of each card from each dealer in my cart. I do not know how many times I have seen a card that cost $.25 on the BMP only be ruined by a dealer charging $3.57 for S/H. I think I have one of the more reasonable S/H charges on the BMP, $2.23 to Canada and $2.47 to the US. Once I find the dealer that has the best overall price with shipping I go to their storefront (you can click on their name in your shopping cart) and see what else they have.
Bought there several times. Shipping costs do get out of hand Internationally (automatically due to the system) when ordering several cards though.
You are correct, it is all due to the weight structure of each card. Each card on the site defaults to .3 OZ. You can order two cards W/O the shipping costs going up. If you order 5 cards the S/H goes up again. This kills international orders for me because who is going to pay close to $5.00 for 6 cards? I mean besides Ebay where I see some sellers charging $4.00 for the first card and $1.00 for each additional card

wned:
I've bought from there a bunch of times. Great for filling in player PC's. You can run a search for free shipping, or some dealers offer free shipping depending on the amount you buy.
The minimum free shipping threashold is $50.00 no matter what the dealer. We have options to exclude/include options. Beckett will not allow dealers to set their own free shipping guidelines. So if you find a dealer that offers free shipping (it will give you a total on your shopping cart as to how far away you are from the free shipping threashold) you have to hit $50.00.
Good for filling stuff from the low-end wantlists. There's some bad dealers over there, but you won't have problems with most of them.
Andy - Please forward the names of all dealers you had issues with to
[email protected]. As with any site there are always a few bad apples.