Dilema - Help me decide on a trade offer!!!!!!

[suitman19]

I have been approached by another Yzerman collector for this card:

They have offered me - straight up:
02/03 Rick Nash SP Authentic Rookie BV $200

It is really tempting........ but it would probably mean the end of my persoanl white whale collection of Yzerman Jersey Numbered Cards. To trade this one away - would kinda hurt - buit the Nash is a nice offering. And it is probably a fair offer.

What do my fellow collectors think???????
Thanks Bruce

 

[Icemanjj]

Ooooo, that's a tight decision to make. If I held up both cards and said "I am going to set one on fire. Choose which one survives", which one do you pick?

 

[jaywings19]

Putting your "quest" aside... I still keep the Yzerman. There are 999 of those Nash SPA's available. Only 152 of yours... and only 1 with #19. To me, it's a no brainer.

 

[PhilM]

I'm with jay,
you've got a unique one on your hands, and it's a player you like.
I'd keep that over the nash anyday.

 

[jersmi]

Bruce, my vote is keep the Yzerman,,pretty unique card...as you know, you can pick up non-patch r/c's of Nash and others pretty cheap on the bay...but not that card....thats my 2 cents....
Jerry

 

[raybourque77]

Keep the Yzerman. I'm sure you'll be able to find another Nash if you really need it.

 

[brisco10]

Bruce:
No way no how. Yzerman has a better auto. Is a better player. It is a more limited card. It is a buy back. At this rate Nash will not even score 300 goals lockout and all.
Thanks
Ken

 

[mofo88]

I'm with the boys on this one, Being the #19 in the print run makes it very easy to keep especially if your a Detroit fan!
Thanks!

 

[LSOH]

Hello,

The offer seems to be pretty fair, but in my opinion..........................

The Yzerman is #19/152........Nuff Said !

Keep The Yzerman my man, it's a truly unique piece of cardboard. I'm sure you can track down another Nash somewhere else. Your choice though !

Thanks
Eli

 

[Kariya44]

Definately keep the Yzerman! BTW-Did you ever find anything from my wantlist? PLMK.

Thanks,
Justin

 

[Drewphoria]

Yzerman - Hall of Fame career.
Nash - Who knows.

Yzerman for sure. Especially with it being numbered 19.

 

[defense44]

Im with Jay also, keep the Yzerman espically with the 19/xx...

Defense44

 

[Bulk-Buyer]

Keep the Yzerman, your quest for the #19 is more important than a card #d/999 and is readily available on ebay for approximately half high bv or less.

 

[wingnut888]

Bruce, I think my eyes are burning after reading what I just read!!!!
Don't be goofy and keep the Stevie...Go buy a Nash and be done with it!!

 

[telemakhos3]

Take the Nash and run...
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Just kidding!

You can always get a different Nash, but the guy you're trading with will never let you get your hands back on the Yzerman.

 

[eoerikson3]

Although Nash is a great player in yesteryear's game and currently in Europe and the potential exists for him to do so much more in the NHL I would still keep the unique piece you have in the Yzerman. Good luck in the quest.

 

[jaywings19]

So far, 3 people have voted for the Nash SPA. I'm just curious who those people are... and why they haven't voiced the opinions in writing.

 

[DredJAw]

Hey Bruce,

I have a Rick Nash SPA for sale. You can basically have your cake and eat it too. PM me if interested.

 

[sprague11]

By any other serial number, Id say Toss a coin.

#19 though ... hold it.

 

[kdema]

to trade or not to trade

no brainer stevie is your man. if you want that nash another will come
swimming by eventually. you'll never see another 19/152 out. keith