mv23
Registered Trader
Couple of years ago (a lot of projects going at the same time
) after reading Terry Ryan's "Tales Of A First-round Nothing: My Life as an NHL Footnote", I started looking into players who were drafted in the first round but never made it to the NHL (Ryan did play 8 games in the NHL but gave me the inspiration here).
Here is my celebration of these extremely talented hockey players who for whatever reason were never able to take that final step from being a first round draft pick to play in the NHL.
I'm skipping the 1963 to 1978 Amateur Drafts and starting from 1979, when they started calling it the Entry Draft.
1979
None (all played in the NHL)
Well sort of starting from 1979. This was an exceptional year, largely helped by the "juniors" from the disbanded WHA who were now eligible for the NHL draft. Even the player with the least NHL games from the first round of this year's draft, Ray Allison, was relatively established with 238 career NHL games.
1980
14th overall by the NY Rangers Jim Malone C Toronto Marlboros [OHA]
Jim is the little brother of Greg Malone (700 NHL games with the Penguins, Whalers, Nordiques) and father of Brad Malone (currently with the Oilers). His career was cut short by a knee injury which eventually forced him to retire after the 1984-85 season. Jim played in three of the big minor leagues of the time (AHL/CHL/IHL) with a combined total of 66 points in 146 games. No cardboard appearances for him so we will have to do with this photo of him with the Tulsa Oilers (Central Hockey League).
1981
17th overall by the Buffalo Sabres Jiri Dudacek Kladno [CZE]
“Dudacek” - would be the answer to the question of who was the first Czechoslovak player drafted in the first round of the NHL Entry Draft. He never made it to North America (I guess at that time it would have meant defecting from Czechoslovakia) but represented his nation in two Canada Cups. Jiri has 400 games and 293 points in the Czechoslovakian league to his name. His only card/sticker appearance seems to be from the 1983 Semic World Championships sticker set, although he never made the final cut to play in that tournament.
19th overall by the Montreal Canadiens Jan Ingman Farjestads BK Karlstad [SEL]
Jan Ingman played his whole career for Farjestad in the top league in Sweden and racked up 244 points in 339 games. He never represented Sweden in any Olympics or adult World Championships. Jan appears in several Semic/Panini stickers from the elite league in Sweden
20th overall by the St. Louis Blues Marty Ruff D Lethbridge Broncos [WHL]
Marty Ruff is one of the four Ruff brothers, Lindy being naturally the most famous. His career was ended by a knee injury as well. Marty combined for 29 points in 96 games in IHL/CHL before his retirement. No cards as far as I know and I could not track down any photos etc on Ebay.
1982
19th overall by the Montreal Canadiens Alain Heroux F Chicoutimi Sagueneens [QMJHL]
Alain played 52 games and gathered 20 points over two seasons in the AHL. I don't know much about Alan, apart from the fact that his brother Yves was a one game wonder in the NHL. No cards for Alain as far as I know.
1983
None (all played in the NHL)
The weakest link, judging by games played, was the current Head Coach of the Boston Bruins, Bruce Cassidy, with 36.
1984
13th overall by the Minnesota North Stars David Quinn D Kent H.S. [Conn.]
It says something about David Quinn's character and his love for the game that he ever played in the minor leagues at all. In 1986 he was diagnosed with a rare disorder which prevents his blood from clotting properly and he was forced to retire from the game. In 1992 David was able to find funding to fight the disorder and presume his playing career. He played half a season in the AHL and almost a full season in IHL before retiring in 1993. David totalled 21 points in 79 across these two minor leagues. He is better known as a coach, currently with the NY Rangers.
20th overall by the NY Islanders Duncan MacPherson D Saskatoon Blades [WHL]
Several years ago I remember reading articles about Duncan MacPherson. There are some very well written ones for example the one in the Esquire magazine which should be easy to find online. Unfortunately, his is not a happy story. In 1989 Duncan had given up hope of making it into the NHL and left to play in Scotland after 157 games in the AHL/IHL combined, with 31 points on the score sheet. Before he ever made it to Scotland he went missing in Austria whilst on skiing holiday. His body was found only 14 years later in 2003 in the mountains under melting ice and snow.
1985
17th overall by the Calgary Flames Chris Biotti D Belmont Hill H.S. [Mass.]
Couldn't gather much info about Biotti, apart from the fact that he is Harvard educated and a successful banker. He played three seasons with the Salt Lake Golden Eagles (189 games, 74 points) in the IHL, before heading to Italy for three seasons.
1986
16th overall by the Calgary Flames George Pelawa Bemidji H.S. [Minn.]
Pelawa's life was sadly cut very short. He died in a car accident three months after the draft.
1987
19th overall by the Calgary Flames Bryan Deasley L U. of Michigan [CCHA]
Deasley mostly played in the IHL, where he appeared in 211 games for Salt Lake, registering 107 points. He also played half a season in the AHL with the Halifax Citadels where he registered 20 points in 37 games.
21st overall by the Edmonton Oilers Peter Soberlak L Swift Current Broncos [WHL]
Soberlak spent his whole professional career with the Cape Breton Oilers. He managed 70 points in 152 games. A search on the interwebs also tells me that he was a very good fighter, but unfortunately (or fortunately) he absolutely hated it.
1988
16th overall by the NY Islanders Kevin Cheveldayoff D Brandon Wheat Kings [WHL]
These days everybody knows Cheveldayoff as the General Manager of the Jets, but he was a punishing d-man drafted 16th overall by the Islanders in 1987. In 276 AHL/IHL games he sat 642 minutes in the sin bin. He was also a casualty of a career ending knee injury.
17th overall by the Detroit Red Wings Kory Kocur R Saskatoon Blades [WHL]
Kory Kocur is Joey's cousin which I remember from Kory's Score card. He is one of those players from the early 90s who have an RC card but never played in the NHL. Kory was more of a finesse player, getting near point per game in roughly 150 IHL games. He was much less productive in the AHL, but definitely never a fighter.
1989
15th overall by the Edmonton Oilers Jason Soules D Niagara Falls Thunder [OHL]
Not sure what happened to Soules but he only appeared 52 times for the Cape Breton Oilers, notching 9 assists. He also made it to an Upper Deck NHL card as an Oiler, but let's keep the style intact and go here with his AHL card instead.
Will make a break here and take on the 90s next time around

Here is my celebration of these extremely talented hockey players who for whatever reason were never able to take that final step from being a first round draft pick to play in the NHL.
I'm skipping the 1963 to 1978 Amateur Drafts and starting from 1979, when they started calling it the Entry Draft.
1979
None (all played in the NHL)
Well sort of starting from 1979. This was an exceptional year, largely helped by the "juniors" from the disbanded WHA who were now eligible for the NHL draft. Even the player with the least NHL games from the first round of this year's draft, Ray Allison, was relatively established with 238 career NHL games.
1980

14th overall by the NY Rangers Jim Malone C Toronto Marlboros [OHA]
Jim is the little brother of Greg Malone (700 NHL games with the Penguins, Whalers, Nordiques) and father of Brad Malone (currently with the Oilers). His career was cut short by a knee injury which eventually forced him to retire after the 1984-85 season. Jim played in three of the big minor leagues of the time (AHL/CHL/IHL) with a combined total of 66 points in 146 games. No cardboard appearances for him so we will have to do with this photo of him with the Tulsa Oilers (Central Hockey League).
1981

17th overall by the Buffalo Sabres Jiri Dudacek Kladno [CZE]
“Dudacek” - would be the answer to the question of who was the first Czechoslovak player drafted in the first round of the NHL Entry Draft. He never made it to North America (I guess at that time it would have meant defecting from Czechoslovakia) but represented his nation in two Canada Cups. Jiri has 400 games and 293 points in the Czechoslovakian league to his name. His only card/sticker appearance seems to be from the 1983 Semic World Championships sticker set, although he never made the final cut to play in that tournament.

19th overall by the Montreal Canadiens Jan Ingman Farjestads BK Karlstad [SEL]
Jan Ingman played his whole career for Farjestad in the top league in Sweden and racked up 244 points in 339 games. He never represented Sweden in any Olympics or adult World Championships. Jan appears in several Semic/Panini stickers from the elite league in Sweden
20th overall by the St. Louis Blues Marty Ruff D Lethbridge Broncos [WHL]
Marty Ruff is one of the four Ruff brothers, Lindy being naturally the most famous. His career was ended by a knee injury as well. Marty combined for 29 points in 96 games in IHL/CHL before his retirement. No cards as far as I know and I could not track down any photos etc on Ebay.
1982
19th overall by the Montreal Canadiens Alain Heroux F Chicoutimi Sagueneens [QMJHL]
Alain played 52 games and gathered 20 points over two seasons in the AHL. I don't know much about Alan, apart from the fact that his brother Yves was a one game wonder in the NHL. No cards for Alain as far as I know.
1983
None (all played in the NHL)
The weakest link, judging by games played, was the current Head Coach of the Boston Bruins, Bruce Cassidy, with 36.
1984

13th overall by the Minnesota North Stars David Quinn D Kent H.S. [Conn.]
It says something about David Quinn's character and his love for the game that he ever played in the minor leagues at all. In 1986 he was diagnosed with a rare disorder which prevents his blood from clotting properly and he was forced to retire from the game. In 1992 David was able to find funding to fight the disorder and presume his playing career. He played half a season in the AHL and almost a full season in IHL before retiring in 1993. David totalled 21 points in 79 across these two minor leagues. He is better known as a coach, currently with the NY Rangers.

20th overall by the NY Islanders Duncan MacPherson D Saskatoon Blades [WHL]
Several years ago I remember reading articles about Duncan MacPherson. There are some very well written ones for example the one in the Esquire magazine which should be easy to find online. Unfortunately, his is not a happy story. In 1989 Duncan had given up hope of making it into the NHL and left to play in Scotland after 157 games in the AHL/IHL combined, with 31 points on the score sheet. Before he ever made it to Scotland he went missing in Austria whilst on skiing holiday. His body was found only 14 years later in 2003 in the mountains under melting ice and snow.
1985

17th overall by the Calgary Flames Chris Biotti D Belmont Hill H.S. [Mass.]
Couldn't gather much info about Biotti, apart from the fact that he is Harvard educated and a successful banker. He played three seasons with the Salt Lake Golden Eagles (189 games, 74 points) in the IHL, before heading to Italy for three seasons.
1986
16th overall by the Calgary Flames George Pelawa Bemidji H.S. [Minn.]
Pelawa's life was sadly cut very short. He died in a car accident three months after the draft.
1987

19th overall by the Calgary Flames Bryan Deasley L U. of Michigan [CCHA]
Deasley mostly played in the IHL, where he appeared in 211 games for Salt Lake, registering 107 points. He also played half a season in the AHL with the Halifax Citadels where he registered 20 points in 37 games.

21st overall by the Edmonton Oilers Peter Soberlak L Swift Current Broncos [WHL]
Soberlak spent his whole professional career with the Cape Breton Oilers. He managed 70 points in 152 games. A search on the interwebs also tells me that he was a very good fighter, but unfortunately (or fortunately) he absolutely hated it.
1988

16th overall by the NY Islanders Kevin Cheveldayoff D Brandon Wheat Kings [WHL]
These days everybody knows Cheveldayoff as the General Manager of the Jets, but he was a punishing d-man drafted 16th overall by the Islanders in 1987. In 276 AHL/IHL games he sat 642 minutes in the sin bin. He was also a casualty of a career ending knee injury.

17th overall by the Detroit Red Wings Kory Kocur R Saskatoon Blades [WHL]
Kory Kocur is Joey's cousin which I remember from Kory's Score card. He is one of those players from the early 90s who have an RC card but never played in the NHL. Kory was more of a finesse player, getting near point per game in roughly 150 IHL games. He was much less productive in the AHL, but definitely never a fighter.
1989

15th overall by the Edmonton Oilers Jason Soules D Niagara Falls Thunder [OHL]
Not sure what happened to Soules but he only appeared 52 times for the Cape Breton Oilers, notching 9 assists. He also made it to an Upper Deck NHL card as an Oiler, but let's keep the style intact and go here with his AHL card instead.
Will make a break here and take on the 90s next time around