You are absolutely right on both counts. Besides a third consecutive Nat'l Championship and another Heisman run, the negatives waaaaay out weigh the positives for another season wtih the "men of Troy" (insert Fleetwood Mac music here...)
Of greater import is who is gonna pick him up in the draft? The Niners might, but I get a feeling they are still interrested in developing one of their previous draft pics. Bears? No way. Browns? Maybe, but who knows? Maybe a team trades down and lets another team that could use a potential franchise QB....Hello, Green Bay!