Need Some Help with this Team Canada Master Collection Carf

[Excon]

I joined 2 group breaks for the Team Canada Master Collection release and was lucky to land a sweet Gretzky Auto (incoming) but also hit this dual auto of Larry Robinson and Bobby Hull 19/25. Unfortunately, it has some fairly significant bottom left corner creasing (a fairly evident and deep ding) and a smaller crease in the top left back corner.

I contacted UD and was told that they would replace the card at Beckett value (I had asked for a comparable dual if possible in Team Canad attire but was told there was no guarantees).

Given the paucity of this product broken, I have not come across another copy of this card to gauge value, nor do I own a subscription to Beckett.

I was hoping that a fellow member would be able to tell me what value Beckett has for this card.

In addition I am faced with the following options:
1) Send it in for a replacement hoping for the best
2) Keep the card
3) List it on ebay for BIN/BO

Comments apprecieted

 

[99wgretzky99]

I'd send it back to UD and tell them to shove it up their ***. What a joke.

 

[Excon]

I'd send it back to UD and tell them to shove it up their ***. What a joke.

If only . UD really did not do a great job on this release.

 

[t-rex604]

I had a Corey perry scripted swatch jumbo jersey. All eight corners were white and in that condition I just couldnt keep it nor sell it for a bag of peanuts either. So I sent it back,I have no clue what I'm getting back in return but I requested tarasenko stuff ,so we'll see.

 

[gomaz]

I'd send it back to UD and tell them to shove it up their ***. What a joke.

Out of curiosity, if Larry or Bobby dropped this card on the ground resulting in that dinged corner, what should UD have done?

1. Removed this card #19/25 from the pack-out?
2. Scolded Bobby or Larry for damaging the product?
3. Remove Bobby or Larry from their autograph roster to teach them a lesson?
4. Had them sign two copies of each card in the event damage happened? (which would inevitably result in both copies hitting the market)
5. Wait for it to get pulled and deal with the return if and when it happens?

In all seriousness, I do not know what the right answer is, but I do not think the proper response is to tell them to shove it up their arse. That is a response better suited for a greasy scalper.

 

[99wgretzky99]

LOL ok my bad that was a bit harsh. I suppose send it back for a replacement and reserve comment until seeing what is sent out.

I thought about the idea of the breakers damaging the card but this set has had many issues.

 

[Excon]

Thanks for all those who voted. I have sent it in. I'll post a S&T when the replacement arrives.