Opinions needed on value of this card

[The LumberJake]

I am in the middle of a trade right now with another board member over this card. Its the Damaged Roy/Sakic/40 the books at $250. I dont really know what value to put on it since it has the crease in it. Here are a few scans of the card.

Here is a picture of the card straite on. You cant notice anything in this scan.

Close up of the crease in the reflection of the light

And it goes to the other side of the seam a bit

The crease is only on one side of the card and isnt on the back. If anyone has any idea on what kind of value I should put on this card, please help.

Jake

 

[PenaltyMan]

I said btn fiddy and eighty-fi'
Creased bling is still bling
-
Wes

 

[Gretzkycards]

It is still a great card and I think it should still hold about 50 or more percent if its value

 

[DredJAw]

I think BV should be about cut in half... so 50-85 sounds about right

 

[bryanstarock]

$50-85..imo

 

[Bulk-Buyer]

Surface layer crease or not, its creased...value is in the eye of the beholder now. I say under $50, well under $50.

 

[danvincent78]

I also put in my vote for under 50 pretty early on. It might be worth more to a serious collector, but to me it would be worth under $50.
Daniel

 

[Neely Collector]

If you need a dishwasher to wash dishes, what good is a broken dishwasher? 50, imo, is still too much. So I out myself in this position, what if, that was a Neely/Bourque card worth 250 mint. And I had that big of a crease on it.... first off, I wouln't take it, because I don't like damaged cards... if it was a hard card to come buy, being worth 250, I wouldn't trade more than 50-60 in BV for it... EVEN if it was a Neely. Why? I can always get a non-damaged one later, and not have it kill me to trade away this damaged one for a price I over paid, or traded for.