Redemption Replacement... Unsure how to feel

[T_Terry]

Hey all,

UPS showed up at the door this morning with a package. Opening it up and reading the letter inside I had learned it was a replacement for my two 2009 Main Event Marks Poker Autos. Now, here is what I had outstanding.

2009 Main Event Marks Poker Autograph CLUB Chris Ferguson
2009 Main Event Marks Poker Autograph DIAMOND Phil Ivey xx/50

I expected something special for the Ivey, seeing he is one of the best in the game. Ivey signatures are hard to come by and with this one being numbered to xx/50, I expected a nice auto in return. Now from what I hear the book value of these cards are higher than the two autos but unless I'm missing something I am a bit disappointed on what I got in return.

Here's what was inside.

Not scanned: One Pack of 2009 Stealth - which contained four base and a Harvick Confidential insert.

A snap case included:

Card One:

Doesn't show well on the scan, but there is some slight chipping on the bottom.

Card Two:

Card Three:

So how do you guys think I made out?

 

[bgggg2001]

hosed!!!!!

 

[cards-gotta-go]

Ivey, like you said, is a super tough auto, never mind that he's the best player in the world.

You got hosed. And not gently.

 

[wildfan1833]

Ya you got the SHAFT on that one

 

[dahabsfan]

I just finished swapping out my Ivey, Hansen, Ferguson and Ferguson Diamond autos and worked one on one with a rep for replacement. What you got was nothing short of violated.

Darren

 

[T_Terry]

I emailed them Friday to see what they can do, I expect to hear back from them on Tuesday. If not, they'll hear from me!