Trouble deciding which Giguere patch to keep. Opinions wanted!

[lukko]

Hi,

Yes, you guessed (more 2002-03 UD Mask Collection Patches.... ). I received another Giguere patch today, and now I have to decide which one to keep. Yes, I'm only keeping one of them for the PC. My downgrade is already spoken for.

Both cards have 3 colours. I do like the colours and the V-shape on #11. #13 is also pretty neat (looks like the tape of one of the sticks in the emblem) and is almost identical to the Kariya patch I already have. My "problem" is: do I want two identical patches of the Anaheim players in the set (keep #11) or do I want two different (coloured) Anaheim patches in my set?

Which card would you keep and why? Please bear in mind I am only keeping one of them. Comments are very welcome!

Regards, Patrick

 

[langway05]

Patrick

I'd have to go with the 11/20. As the 13/20 is too similar to the Kariya in your signature.

'Just my two cents thrown in!'

Brian

 

[GabbyGuy]

Patrick, my preference is for unlucky #13. Even though it is similar to the Kariya, I base it on a Giggy...so I don't care what the Kariya looks like...I think the #13 patch looks nicer for that card. My opinion only.

If you like both and cannot decide, then look each card over closely and take the one that is in better shape (corners, edges, etc).

Other one going to Jerry by chance??

 

[Khabby]

#11.......just looks better

 

[hccollector]

11 would be my choice

D

 

[Big Tall]

#11 easily

 

[The Big M]

11/20 without doubt.
Michael.

 

[JPatterson#1Fan]

#11 here too.

 

[Magootz]

Got to be #11

 

[chrisjames105]

11/20 is way better, my opinion.

 

[lukko]

WOW !!! Score is 8-1 in favour of #11 so far!! I thought it would have been much closer ?!! Thanks for the input so far!!

Still interested in your choices though!! LMK!

Curt - You're right . My downgrade will go to Jerry. After helping Jerry to complete the set, I'm now also trying to help out a friend of his (he'll end up with Jerry's Giguere).

Regards, Patrick

 

[Chinner]

11/20 would be the one I kept...but I would keep them both.

 

[ZP9]

I'd go with 13/20 just because it is a bit more eye catching IMO.

 

[gratzi]

I like #11 better

 

[Bossy22]

#13 would be my choice.

 

[CadenZ]

Easy decision for me: 11/20 looks much nicer, especially with the design of the card. The colours match the overall look of the card much better. Plus the "V" is nice!

 

[lukko]

Thanks for the input so far!! #11 leads by 11-3.

Regards, Patrick