Like I did on the Facebook one...
Ovechkin (4), McDavid (2), Bossy (2).
Orr (5), Potvin (1)
Price (1)
I went with those three forwards because I figured they would really mesh. Great players sometimes can't play well together; see Canada Cup when Bossy and Gretzky just couldn't click; they separated them after one period of the first game.
With the greatest player of all-time (Orr) feeding those three, and one of the top five 'defensive defencemen' of all-time (Potvin) covering him, I don't even need a goalie... but Price is not a bad choice.