johnse27
Verified Trader,
Great card and auto Curt! Awesome story as well!
Post an Autograph and critique it
- Thread starter Avalanchefan21
- Start date
johnse27
Verified Trader,
This card from the 04-05 SP Authentic is a mix of good and bad autos, topped off by the Beliveau auto at the end. Hossa's is a bit weak, Lafleur, Theodore and Ryder are ok and Beliveau's is great. I give it an 8/10 for star power and the final auto.
GabbyGuy
Upstanding Member,
Great card, Paul! I agree, the Hossa brothers both have weird autos...and I never got the "Guy" part of Lafleur' auto (but he's consistent). ???
The Beliveau makes the card, for sure!
--Curt
johnse27
Verified Trader,
Here is another auto of a classic line for the Islanders. We talked about Bossy before but Trottier and Gillies also have classy autos. I would give this an 9/10 IMO.
GabbyGuy
Upstanding Member,
GabbyGuy
Upstanding Member,
My next auto isn't any player who has won the Stanley Cup, but it is someone who has held it more than anyone in history. I'm talking the "Keeper of the Stanley Cup", Phil Pritchard. With his Bob Nystrom-like hair, Phil has been the Keeper since 1988. Some of the stories he must have! 
I have one auto card of his from 2018 Goodwin. Two large "P"s and some chicken scratch in his autograph. I give it a 6/10.
--Curt
I have one auto card of his from 2018 Goodwin. Two large "P"s and some chicken scratch in his autograph. I give it a 6/10.
--Curt
mq13
New Member, Must Send First ,
Awesome Auto!My next auto is another old-timer...who usually have awesome autos! This one is Frank Clancy. I love the old guys who sign with their nickname as well. In this case Frank "King" Clancy.
That is always a 10/10 in my book!
View attachment 20781
--Curt
johnse27
Verified Trader,
That's cool Curt!
GabbyGuy
Upstanding Member,
Another old-timer with a classic auto.
Bobby Baun
I give it a 9.5/10
--Curt
Bobby Baun
I give it a 9.5/10
--Curt
johnse27
Verified Trader,
Here is another of Bobby Baun and how consistent his legible auto is!
GabbyGuy
Upstanding Member,
The next auto critique is for future HOFer Marc-Andre Fleury. His auto is simple with basically his initials MF and a couple squiggles, a dot, and his number 29. The auto has remained pretty consistent since his rookie year.
I give it a 7/10
2024-25 Synergy Sygnatures Fleury 2/10
2022-23 Artifacts Net Gear Auto Fleury 19/25
--Curt
I give it a 7/10
2024-25 Synergy Sygnatures Fleury 2/10
2022-23 Artifacts Net Gear Auto Fleury 19/25
--Curt
johnse27
Verified Trader,
Ok my next auto card is the future of the Auto Cards coming out. This is a 18-19 SP Authentic Sign of the Times 8's with some of the top young stars in the league. There isn't much difference between the best auto and the worst cause they are all pretty bad in most ways. I give them a 3/10 for their autos! IMO Svechnikov's might be the best lol!
