Being screwed by a member here: bearlyjb... please read

[peulyen]

To everyone here... I would raise some serious concerns about this seller.

Barry here sold me a 05-06 Cup Emblems of Endorsement card that had a crease (he says manufacturer defect) that was not disclosed and now that I have received the card, and saw the defect, I want my money back. The seller is refusing to refund me the money.

I will be adding pictures in a second to this post.

BUYER BEWARE!


His sale thread is here:

P

Post in thread 'Upper Deck The Cup from PC'

Mar 22, 2025

Not disclosing something that's there, is just plain wrong. Period. The picture you took didn't show it and you didn't describe anything like that in the listing.

• peulyen

• 

Card that i bought is here:

2005-06 Upper Deck The Cup Emblem of Endorsement #EE-JB Beliveau SN 08/15 | eBay

Find many great new & used options and get the best deals for 2005-06 Upper Deck The Cup Emblem of Endorsement #EE-JB Beliveau SN 08/15 at the best online prices at eBay! Free shipping for many products!

www.ebay.com

No description about any damage to the card.


And when I got it here's what that looked like. See pictures.



He refuses to refund me the money yet acknowledges he knew about the damage as he calls it manufacturer issue.


Unfortunately I did send him e-transfer so I can't just dispute it. But what i can do is tell everyone about it, for them not deal with this guy. The guy has over 3k feedback and was here on hobbyinsider, so I assumed he would be okay.

This is just not right.

I will be posting this further on instagram and facebook everywhere. If you're thinking of dealing with him, BUYER BEWARE. I just wouldn't.


Frustrated and angry,
Lu

 

[Tachyon]

Cannot say I have dealt with this member but I recognize the name.

Yes, I agree with you. I would 100% not want to pay what you paid given the condition it arrived in as it was NOT disclosed.

I would either want my money back and to send the card back or get a partial refund. If the card is valued at $1000 but you can realistically only sell it for $800 because of the damage then I would want $200 back.

People do this all the time on eBay. I just got money back for a Draisaitl card that had a crease down the back. Yes this specific card was only $7 but I got a refund for it and I plan to give it away for free to someone who just wants the card. I would have been uncomfortable selling this card for over $1 so it is now only worth $1. I Would want the rest of the money back.

Sounds to me like this bearlyjb person is in the wrong. It was sold to you as NR-MT but only arrived in Fair condition then I want the difference back in refund or store credit-type deal.

Good-luck and keep us posted.

 

[peulyen]

I appreciate your message. At this time, nothing has happened with resolving this. Nothing from Barry, nor from the admin team here on hobbyin. so no real update. unfortunately.

 

[frankiefives]

Disregard my post. I just noticed the sale thread.

 

[gomaz]

I appreciate your message. At this time, nothing has happened with resolving this. Nothing from Barry, nor from the admin team here on hobbyin. so no real update. unfortunately.

Well, I am still admin here and did give it the gool 'ol college try but Barry refuses to take any accountability. Wish my efforts were more fruitful for you Lu!

 

[peulyen]

Well, I am still admin here and did give it the gool 'ol college try but Barry refuses to take any accountability. Wish my efforts were more fruitful for you Lu!

Sorry, yes, I meant nothing more than what you posted over on the buy thread, Jeremy. Nothing more to add. That's all i meant.

 

[TBstanleycup04]

He should 100% refund you !
No ethics... Sad

 

[quincy]

Having had an opportunity to see the card in question up close and in person: It is quite obvious on inspection, it should have been disclosed, and the seller's behaviour is quite frankly inexcusable.