can somebody explain this to me?

[marclemagnifique]

I owns this card a few months ago, I make it grade to make the sales easier, since this card had a major defects on it :

I found this today on ebay :

http://www.ebay.ca/itm/2013-14-PANI...233523?hash=item25b6f3fdf3:g:q48AAOSwuAVWx7Q9


Can somebody explain to me how this card, #'d 29/29 can repair by itself?

 

[foley2k]

If you spend lots of money with beckett, they will give a higher grade, or so ive read.

This is part of the reason why I dislike grading a card.

 

[dahabsfan]

To me it looks like someone got a replacement....the serial # stamping appears to be in a different location.

Darren

 

[Triple B]

To me it looks like someone got a replacement....the serial # stamping appears to be in a different location.

Darren

I agree with this...it looks like the number was stamped a bit more towards the right.

 

[NNeves]

There's no integrity left in this hobby. Surely Beckett had a record of having already graded this card.

 

[HighEndPlease]

^ It's not the same card. The "10" graded by Beckett is totally different card.

Like others have said, the serial numbered in different locations.

If you look at the lettering on Mackinnon's stick, it's not the same card.

Corners don't look the same either.

 

[marclemagnifique]

I agree this isn't the same card, but why there 2 of the same cards, with the same # in circulation...

Why Panini decide to make another similar card, if this is a replacement?

 

[Nick2317]

I agree this isn't the same card, but why there 2 of the same cards, with the same # in circulation...

Why Panini decide to make another similar card, if this is a replacement?

if its a replacement the original card was sent back and destroyed ....

 

[Triple B]

I agree this isn't the same card, but why there 2 of the same cards, with the same # in circulation...

Why Panini decide to make another similar card, if this is a replacement?

Someone bought your card, broke it out of the holder, sent it back to Panini with an obvious surface flaw (hence the "6" on the original grade), Panini replaced it (and, as stated above, destroyed the damaged one) and that person sent it back to BGS to have it graded and got a 10.

I'm guessing they got a steal on the card you sold and turned it into a golden egg.

 

[JR]

What seems strange to me is how did they get this replaced? Obviously Panini replaced it, but can you send in any old banged up card and get it replaced? If marcelemagnifique pulled it from a pack,and sent it along with a receipt that would make sense. But this steal..deals dude got hooked up somehow...

 

[odjickfan]

I pulled a damaged card from Totally Certified 13-14 in december 2014 and I got a replacement for it a couple of months later. But I had my receipt from the box seller and all.

Maybe your buyer sent the card to Panini with a receipt from a box of Titanium that he bought??

 

[JR]

Maybe your buyer sent the card to Panini with a receipt from a box of Titanium that he bought??

 

[Davis]

I would bet that whoever bought your card lied to Panini that he/she pulled it from a pack damaged and sent it in for replacement. I would email Panini to let them know that someone scammed them. They would easily be able to look up who it was and put a note on that persons account.