Downie facing disciplinary action

Elliotte Friedman twitter "Re, Downie: supplemental discipline not automatic under Rule 70.2 if it's a legal line change. This might be considered one. We'll see."
 
even the Rangers announcers (want to say Sam and JD but JD is gone now) was surprised by his move... it sounded like

and Downie is gone for 10 games i believe
 
How does the rule apply when it is a stoppage in play, one player goes to the bench, and he comes on to replace him? He did not jump onto the ice while everyone else was engaged to join an altercation. Not defending him, but he may not be subject to the automatic 10 games, no?
 
How does the rule apply when it is a stoppage in play, one player goes to the bench, and he comes on to replace him? He did not jump onto the ice while everyone else was engaged to join an altercation. Not defending him, but he may not be subject to the automatic 10 games, no?

He may not get 10 because of this "loophole" but he will get something. I hope Shanny gives him the full 10
 
Stoppage in play or whatever but basing that as a technicality would allow the entire team to jump on the ice, not just Downie. if he's not counted on the ice at the time of goal simple fact is he jumped on afterwards.

EDIT - I would now like a dual shield card with pics of Selanne and Anisimov in their respective poses. :)
 
Last edited:
woot!! I am so glad downie did that. its that many less games I have hear about that guy. really one of my most hated players in the game besides avery lol
 
woot!! I am so glad downie did that. its that many less games I have hear about that guy. really one of my most hated players in the game besides avery lol

Awww....too bad. ;)

erlendssontrib Erik Erlendsson said:
Sounds like Steve Downie will be hit with a fine for coming off on a legal line change to join an altercation, but no suspension
 
Sucks to see Downie trashed on so much. He has cleaned up his act a lot more than most people give him credit for. Every team has somebody on it who has done something worse than Downie in the past year. He stuck up for his team when he felt they were disrespected. Job well done!
 
Sucks to see Downie trashed on so much. He has cleaned up his act a lot more than most people give him credit for. Every team has somebody on it who has done something worse than Downie in the past year. He stuck up for his team when he felt they were disrespected. Job well done!

Yeah all anyone can remember is the hit he put on Mcammond during the preseason in his rookie year. Thats it. Pretty pathetic they have missed him actually become a pretty damn good hockey player in the past few years.
 
woot!! I am so glad downie did that. its that many less games I have hear about that guy. really one of my most hated players in the game besides avery lol

There are a lot of players that are worse than Downie. Danny Briere, Patrick Kaleta, Patrick Kane, PK Subban, Milan Lucic, that's just off hand. All a bunch of douchebag punks.
 
There are a lot of players that are worse than Downie. Danny Briere, Patrick Kaleta, Patrick Kane, PK Subban, Milan Lucic, that's just off hand. All a bunch of douchebag punks.

dude. Briere? Kane?

I can see people hating on Looch, Subban and Kaleta, but I want to know why you think the other guys are dbags? Kane and Briere are not like Avery and Downie...
 
There are a lot of players that are worse than Downie. Danny Briere, Patrick Kaleta, Patrick Kane, PK Subban, Milan Lucic, that's just off hand. All a bunch of douchebag punks.

now that list is funny. are we playing which 2 dont belong there? I can kinda see saying Kane is a douche for his off ice run in with the cabbie, but that was 1 time. On ice he hasn't done anything to be included with Kaleta, Lucic, or subban. plus your list is missing Avery, Cooke, and Tootoo
 
Sucks to see Downie trashed on so much. He has cleaned up his act a lot more than most people give him credit for. Every team has somebody on it who has done something worse than Downie in the past year. He stuck up for his team when he felt they were disrespected. Job well done!

Some peoples' ideas of Downie go all the way back to junior and won't ever change.

From Wikipedia:
Downie was selected in the first round, 29th overall, in the 2005 NHL Entry Draft by the Philadelphia Flyers. Not long after being drafted, Downie was suspended for five games early in the 2005–06 OHL season for an on-ice altercation with teammate Akim Aliu. During a practice on September 28, 2005, Downie blindly cross-checked Aliu in the face without warning, knocking out 3 of his teeth, and then proceeded to fight his younger teammate.[1] The incident stemmed from 16-year-old Aliu's refusal to take part in a hazing incident, where he would have been forced to stand naked in a cramped bus bathroom with other rookies.

I don't believe in vilifying someone for one incident long in the past, but since then he's done very little to bring his name out of the mud in my mind.
 
now that list is funny. are we playing which 2 dont belong there? I can kinda see saying Kane is a douche for his off ice run in with the cabbie, but that was 1 time. On ice he hasn't done anything to be included with Kaleta, Lucic, or subban. plus your list is missing Avery, Cooke, and Tootoo

I like how Kaleta gets lumped in with Tootoo, Lucic, and Subban. The guy has been living off his rep since his rookie year. He throws his body around and he aggitates.
 
Some peoples' ideas of Downie go all the way back to junior and won't ever change.

From Wikipedia:


I don't believe in vilifying someone for one incident long in the past, but since then he's done very little to bring his name out of the mud in my mind.

ONE incident? Do you not remember this? He got a 20 game suspension

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=322zqTkL0-c
 

Latest posts

Forum statistics

Threads
390,203
Messages
2,239,321
Members
4,172
Latest member
Singin
Back
Top