Fair Trade?

[Breakaway Dealz]

Would like to get anyones openion as to would this be a fair trade...

I have-

2008-09 SPx #187 JSY AU /499 Luke Schenn RC bv $100

For

2009-10 Upper Deck Champ's Signatures #CSJG Jonas Gustavsson bv $50

I realize I would be trading a card double the amount of the Gustavsson though would you do it?

Please let me know your openion
thanks

 

[Kharlamov17]

No way. Sell the Schenn for $40-50 and buy a Gustavsson on eBay for $15-20.

 

[TheBostonKid]

agreed, keep in mind that you are trading a rookie auto for a non rookie auto...you can sell the schenn and buy the jonas and still have extra in your pocket

 

[drkicker]

If you take away the bv, the Schenn is selling in the 30-60 range and the Gustavsson is selling in the 10-15$ range.

I would sell the Schenn and buy a couple of Gustavsson personally, or ask the other party for more.

 

[Curtis-Sports-Cards]

I agree with Howe1850..sell it and pickup the Gustavsson for cheap

 

[Breakaway Dealz]

thanks everyone for giving the imput. It didn't seem to me to be a fair trade to be honest.

 

[Triple B]

thanks everyone for giving the imput. It didn't seem to me to be a fair trade to be honest.

Always trust your instinct...that there should have been your first "nope".

 

[spooner9ball]

You would be staying true to your username, that's for sure!!

 

[chakhae1]

Wait around and hold the Schenn and trade for "The Monster" cards in the CUP/Ultimate/SPA.