Grade this Gump RC

[BillInDallas]

I know it's not the best way to get a look at a card, but what do you vintage experts think of this Gump Worsley RC that I hit in my History of Hockey break? Except for the upper left corner, it looks to be in pretty good condition and worth of breaking from the case and submitting to PSA:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=p3e2aRkZA5s&list=UUk7tzQtTjl8gZ_Dc9FpvZ-w

The card is at the 21:50 mark.

 

[dburzyn]

I'd conservatively say it would grade an EX 5, with the slight possibility of EX-MT 6.

That one corner is really unfortunate.

thanks,
Dave

 

[terry1hockeyfan]

I would say 4.5 - 5.

 

[BillInDallas]

Well that tempers my enthusiasm a bit! I was thinking that a 6 would be doable as the rest of the card looks pretty decent. That one darn corner...still a very nice card though. I've hit some pretty cool vintage out of the product which frankly has been a bonus.

 

[BillInDallas]

Here is the card along with another vintage RC I pulled...

 

[LaundryRoomTradingCo.]

That's in pretty good condition if you think of it as a 60 year old slip of card board haha! Anyways not calling myself an expert but my guess would be a solid 6 or maybe 7!

 

[hextall27]

I'd conservatively say it would grade an EX 5, with the slight possibility of EX-MT 6.

That one corner is really unfortunate.

thanks,
Dave

I took a guess before reading the comments and this is EXACTLY what i was thinking.

edit: after seeing the scans, it looks like an old tape stain on the left. I would drop it back to 4-5.

 

[Billwinkle]

Printer mark on the left, possible tape mark, one soft corner dirty 4-5 possibly a 6 PSA are brutal so why get it graded?