High Profile Fans - Good Idea, Poor Execution

steveottfan

Verified Trader,
Joined
Nov 18, 2005
Messages
1,106
Reaction score
0
Location
Charlottetown, PEI
I need to vent a little about this subset in 2021-22 UD Fleer Ultra.
I was excited to see this insert announced, I love outside the box thinking like this, but I'm disappointed about the final product. I feel like it was created with minimal effort possible.

A look at the set:
Andrew-Herr.jpg

Andrew-Herr.jpg

Nathan-Dales.jpg

Dylan-Playfair.jpg

Kamilla-Kowal.jpg

Melanie-Scrofano.jpg

Tyler-Johnston.jpg


The issues I have:
1. There are no hockey pictures whatsoever in the entire set. I could easily accept if they even had only a couple hockey photos so if you put the set together, you get the idea of what sport they are fans of. But nope, not one hockey related photo used. Getting a photo of a couple of these guys in a hockey jersey would have required just the smallest amount of effort.

2. No text telling us why they are hockey fans. How hard would it have been to throw together a paragraph, or even a short sentence, about the person or how the card relates to hockey. Tell me why this card is in a hockey set! Heck, even tell me they're famous for being actors on a show called Letterkenny.

3. No base set so no base set with text. This would have been the only excuse for no text/explanations on the autographs.

4. Confusing SP system and a second chance to use a hockey photo wasted. I think the SPs are just different generic photos with no indication of print run.

5. They are NOT an additional hit in the product. I bought a box and my only notable hit was a High Profile Fans autograph. If they are going to be a main part of the product, put in some effort! Had they been thrown in as an extra hit, the poor execution would have been somewhat excusable.

It's also very noticeable that they failed to include Jared Keeso in this set but I won't fault UD for that as he might not have wanted to partake. They also managed a redemption in this small set (Michelle Mylett).

I could put this entire set together, show my partner and she would have no idea what sport it was from.

I feel like this is exactly the kind of set you get when you run a hockey company in Carlsbad, CA with a bunch of people who don't give a damn about the game or hobby.

They didn't even have to rewrite the book.
This is what it looks like when you give half a damn about the cards you create (thanks Panini).
Michael-Ontkean.jpg

Michael-Ontkean.jpg


Rant over.
 
No idea what the point of this set was, I have no idea who any of those “high profile” fans are. If it had “stars” like the older Fans of the Game sets like Carrie Underwood, Will Ferrell, Kelly Clarkson, David Beckham, Vince Vaughn, etc that’s one thing. But with this set I just say, WHO?
 
No idea what the point of this set was, I have no idea who any of those “high profile” fans are. If it had “stars” like the older Fans of the Game sets like Carrie Underwood, Will Ferrell, Kelly Clarkson, David Beckham, Vince Vaughn, etc that’s one thing. But with this set I just say, WHO?

They're all actors on a popular Canadian made show called Letterkenny. It makes it somewhat niche, but I agree, made worse from the fact that the design does not suggest any tie to hockey or the show. Just random people...

Cory
 
They're all actors on a popular Canadian made show called Letterkenny. It makes it somewhat niche, but I agree, made worse from the fact that the design does not suggest any tie to hockey or the show. Just random people...

Cory

" Bonnie McMurray " :thumbsup:
 
I can't really fault UD for the lack of licensing for "Letterkenny". They likely could only use these photoshoot style pictures. No images from the actual show.

And yes, it's disappointing that Keeso and Trevor K Wilson didn't sign. But it's hard to get non athletes to sit down and sign a bunch of stickers.

Speaking as a non-sports collector, I was super happy to see these cards in the product. The fact that UD recognized this very niche Canadian comedy is awesome IMO.
 
My memory is a little fuzzy, but I believe the Ontkean card was the only Slap Shot related card Panini got away with using non-airbrushed imagery from the movie. It was the first card they made related to the movie, the subsequent cards of the Hanson brothers were all in civilian clothes or edited out.

Too bad they didn't get the the Letterkenny rights, would have made it a great card set.
 
My memory is a little fuzzy, but I believe the Ontkean card was the only Slap Shot related card Panini got away with using non-airbrushed imagery from the movie. It was the first card they made related to the movie, the subsequent cards of the Hanson brothers were all in civilian clothes or edited out.

Too bad they didn't get the the Letterkenny rights, would have made it a great card set.

The Paul Newman cut has a very small picture of him from the movie in the top right corner (it's a picture of him sitting on the bench, but really amounts to a head shot). It's not airbrushed though.

I know I've read that Panini had made plans to do Slapshot themed cards, that never came to fruition. I'm assuming licensing was a problem.
 
The Paul Newman cut has a very small picture of him from the movie in the top right corner (it's a picture of him sitting on the bench, but really amounts to a head shot). It's not airbrushed though.

I know I've read that Panini had made plans to do Slapshot themed cards, that never came to fruition. I'm assuming licensing was a problem.

Thanks. I definitely missed seeing the Newman cut.

Went back and looked for articles from that time frame and came across this one. Nancy Dowd wasn't happy with the Hanson/Carlson act carrying on. I imagine she would have been the licensing roadblock to a full slap shot set.

https://www.nytimes.com/2010/04/12/sports/hockey/12slapshot.html

Topps had the Hanson theme in Ginter 2021. Kind of a funny set as well - the triple auto had Chiefs logos, the individual cards did not.
 


Write your reply...

Forum statistics

Threads
389,471
Messages
2,232,865
Members
4,146
Latest member
E_Thom_Tech
Back
Top