Putting Things in Perspective
I'm with you on this. Have only hand one "damaged" bubbler but the card was fine. Had quite a few damaged cards in whiteys.
The bubble mailer IS the standard for deals here on HobbyInsider.net for the reasons stated earlier:
1. Bubblers do not go through automatic sorting machines so they are less likely to get damaged.
2. Bubblers are less likely to get lost.
3. Bubblers in the mailbox put an air of excitement among the dreariness of regular bills.
If you do not send by bubble mailer (which I highly recommend NOT doing), you MUST get your trading partner to agree to how you are sending, which is again why transaction threads must be completely fully.
This discussion has been sidetracked for a variety of reasons - mainly the lack of verifiable date and an erroneous start to the discussion to begin with.
I submit the following data. Since 1971 my companies have shipped well over 1,000,000 items by Canada Post in PWEs, manilla envelopes, padded envelopes, bubble envelopes, corrugated boxes of various make,size and shape. Wore out two Pitney Bowes mailing machines in the process and when I stopped counting in the early nineties had shipped to 63 countries. I think I know a bit about shipping cards and product by mail.
The erroneous assumption. The debate is focused on the choice between a PWE and a bubble envelope. This is a completely bogus choice to begin with.
Throw in manilla envelopes,padded envelopes or any other mailing product and the debate is still bogus and pointless.
The real issue is very simple. A PWE or a bubble envelope or any other mailing product is an inanimate object. Without YOU the shipper it cannot accomplish anything. So the real issue is very simple. Ship properly with the appropriate product for the specific item(s) or do it poorly and risk the consequences.
A few months ago I received a 140 cards from a highly rated vendor on an internet site in a #0 Eco-Lite bubble envelope. 4 teams bags jammed to the limit with 35 cards each. The four team bags were originally placed in a 2 x 2 matrix inside the envelope but were not stabilized within a cardboard sandwich taped on the sides and at the ends. In transit the packs had moved and arrived with one pack diagonally underneath another. Two of the cards were significantly damaged. Not the fault of the envelope, the manufacturers of the various components, the various post offices or people en route. The shipper did not do the job properly. Did not use proper tools and tried to do it on the cheap.
As for items getting lost. Items get lost because of human error. Plain and simple. The packaging has absolutely nothing to do with the item getting lost.
Sumit the following as evidence.
1. Shipment to London, Ontario from Sherbrooke, QC,delayed 5 weeks because a postal worker misread the label and sent it to London, England. Oblivious to the fact that the package did not have any customs declarations attached.
2. Express envelope from Montreal, QC to Philadelphia,Pa. returned to me after seven weeks as undeliverable. On the stamped receipt it was clearly marked as Philadelphia, Pa but en route some one had crossed out the PA and replaced it with NY. The amazing part was that no one else in the chain was able or willing to correct the mistake. Took two months to get a refund for the initial fees.
3. Shipment from Sherbrooke, QC to a USA destination delayed 11 weeks. Properly addressed with appropriate customs declarations. At some point in Canada the parcel was incorrectly placed in an international bag instead of a USA bag. When it arrived back at our Sherbrooke warehouse it had stamps indicating that it had cleared customs in France and Egypt.BTW no contents were damaged or missing.
Again the packaging had absolutely nothing to do with the misdirection or the perception of loss by the customer.