Luca Sbisa, I hate you...

[golgo13]

I think that is a VERY solid replacement on UD's behalf, especially if it is a Giroux Ice Premieres Patch Auto /10. One thing about the dual shield is that Sbisa is on it, which I believe brings the overall value down a bit. I would be a happy camper, congrats :beer:

 

[Rorschach]

Where's the love? UD didn't lose the card but still came through with beaucoup replacement value...

 

[go_leafs]

This is what I was given as a replacement

09-10 SPA Sign Of The Times Triples # Claude Giroux / Jeff Carter / Mike Richards /25
08-09 Cup Printing Plates SPx Yellow #179 Claude Giroux 1/1
08-09 Ice #203 Claude Giroux PATCH AU /10
11-12 Gretzky Team CAnada Shadowbox Auto


Thoughts?

if the Ice Giroux is a Rookie Premiere auto patch /10 with a nice patch, that card can go for BIG money ...

and the gretzky never hurts


yes you did get a shield in return, but in terms of value, i think they are pretty close

 

[LT21Titans27]

That Gretzky shadowbox, wow, those sell for a pretty penny, then three solid PC cards, unless you hate printing plays and the patch is weak...well I think you did well, congrats!

 

[FlyerGuy22]

Yea, I actually needed the triple, and I already have the ice premiere patch, so this one is actually already being dealt. They originally offered a Messier/Gretzky signature patch /35 but I said I didn't want a Rangers card, so they upgraded to the shadowbox.
I fought for the plate actually just to at least get a 1/1 in the deal since it was a 1/1 being replaced.
Overall, I can't complain about value. Just disappointed since back then the rookies only got 1 auto shield in the cup and I thought I had Girouxs locked up.

 

[JD0253]

I'm sure sbisa cashed his check for signing the lost card.

 

[Rorschach]

Luca, if you're a HI member, show us your Giroux PC! Hehe

 

[LuuucnDino]

Maybe he lost it after getting his @&$ kicked in a bar fight in Newport Beach...not the brightest one for sure

 

[Gerber29]

Maybe he lost it after getting his @&$ kicked in a bar fight in Newport Beach...not the brightest one for sure

Please tell us more about the bar fight :devil:

 

[FlyersMatt]

my first reaction....WAT?!?!?!?

my second reaction...Luca Sbisa you f@$%ing idiot! (and this coming from someone who genuinely likes him lol)

I seriously can't believe that is even possible to happen...and they are off their freakin rockers with $700. They should be comparing it only to other top players rookie shields...not scrubs

 

[wildfan1833]

I think you did well. Congrats. Scans of the cards you got might help everyone calm down lol

 

[lindros877]

sorry to here your horror story. I went through the same thing 6 months ago. Does that give mine a bump?