More worth keeping YG or Spx

[Nick2317]

Whats more worth keeping nowadays

The old standby the Young Guns

OR

The Spx auto jersey rookie

If you pick other explain why and please dont say a Cup Rookie cause not everyone can afford one of those

 

[Juular]

YG's a bit classic and have been around forever and really anyone can get a Yg from a blaster to a hobby box, its always fun to find a YG though yea sometimes a "Who's That?!" they add up and ppl are always looking for them thus good tradebait.

 

[The Doaner]

I think the SPX auto jersey will have more value than YG. They are numbered and autos, so it that's why I can say that. The Petr Kalus ( who ?) YG worth 5$ and it's SPx auto/jersey /999 worth 12$ I think it says all

 

[timber09]

I will personally take the YG - classic look and feel. Sure SPx has auto's and jerseys but they are photoshoot jerseys and sticker autos - YG in my collection.

 

[BenDMitchell]

From what I have read on this board in the past, besides The Cup, the best rookie cards to get are SP Authentic Future Watch. Am I right? Any thoughts?

 

[JSOKOL1626]

I prefer SPA too, but of the choices given, i like Young Guns. UD1 and 2 remain the best bang for the buck in the hobby.

 

[missionhocky10]

i put YG, but i would rank the rookies Cup then SPA then YG. yes, the spx has an auto and jersey but i would still rather have the yg

 

[BYOB]

From what I have read on this board in the past, besides The Cup, the best rookie cards to get are SP Authentic Future Watch. Am I right? Any thoughts?

Probably the majority feel that way, but Ice RC's and Ultimate some prefer. I personally prefer the Ice #/99 RC's.

As for the YG vs. SPX I would probably go with the YG. Seems like there is much much more demand for YG's due to set collectors. Not too many SPX set collectors out there. Also the whole photoshoot,sticker thing really isn't some peoples cup of tea.

 

[nucks4cup]

Young gun for me. SPX is a band-aid auto, with a photoshoot jersey, pass.

 

[Hockey-Only]

i personaly say YG's.. there usualy the cards everyone picks up and trades right when it comes out and they become waay more valuable later on..

 

[bigben913]

So if you guys were given the choice between getting a Sid Young Guns or SPX RC for the same price, you would go YG? Doubt it!

 

[AV_Collector]

I went with YG's. I usually pick up a few every year of guys I don't really collect. Sometimes I trade them off later down the road but in most cases I just hold on to it for the PC.

 

[gratzi]

I voted other cause I always try to land a few SPA rookies as they are my favorite.

 

[cremona71]

The Cup> Ice> SPA>Ultimate>YG>SPX

This year I will include Crown Royale as a top tier rookie.

 

[golgo13]

I would take the YG over the SPX just because I loved collecting them when I was a kid when UD Hockey came out

 

[jmatchett]

So if you guys were given the choice between getting a Sid Young Guns or SPX RC for the same price, you would go YG? Doubt it!

If I was selling it, I'd take the SPX. For a collection, YG.
As for the topic, SPA is the best to me, then YG.

 

[bigben913]

If I was selling it, I'd take the SPX. For a collection, YG.
As for the topic, SPA is the best to me, then YG.

Im not saying selling though. Im asking, if you could acquire a Crosby Young Guns or a Crosby SPX for the same price but could get only one, would you really take the YG over the SPX? I guess in your case Richards would be more appropriate.

 

[Avalanchefan21]

Young Guns- Have a classic unique look and hype about them. Plus they don't have GU/autos something popular RCs from 2000 and under never had