Need help in a big trade, please!

[Särås]

Hello!
Ihave been looking for the The Cup Crosby RC to my set...
Now it's looks like i could make a deal to get one!
So this is the cards that he whant from me:

Year Card # Set Player/Players # / # Other info
1979-80 18 OPC Wayne Gretzky KSA 7
1986-07 53 OPC, Blank Back Patrick Roy BGS 8
2001-02 BKK SP Authentic, SOTT Tripple Bure/Kovalchuk/Kovalev 8/15
2002-03 P-RN SP Authentic, Futur Watch patch/Auto Rick Nash 26/100 3 C patch
2002-03 P-RN SP Authentic, Futur Watch patch/Auto Rick Nash 34/100 4 C patch, small star patch
2002-03 P-JS SP Authentic, Futur Watch patch/Auto Jason Spezza 51/100 3 C patch
2002-03 80 UD Premier, Patch Auto RC Rick Nash 73/99 Silver Patch
2002-03 83 UD Premier, Patch Auto RC Jason Spezza 57/99 2 C Patch
2002-03 83 UD Premier, Patch Auto RC Jason Spezza 33/99 3 C Patch
2002-03 81 UD Premier, Patch Auto RC Henrik Zetterberg 44/99 2 C Patch
2002-03 SZ SP Authentic, SOTT Dual Spezza/Zetterberg 34/99
2005-06 EE-PR Ultimate Collection, Endorsed Emblems Auto Patrick Roy 35/35 2 C Patch
2005-06 SN-HL SP Game Used, Significant Numbers Henrik Lundqvist 6/30
2005-06 177 The Cup Patch Auto Henrik Lundqvist 79/199 3 C Patch, big star patch
2005-06 91 Ultimate Collection Sidney Crosby 17/299
2005-06 AD-PR SP Game Used, Auto Draft Patrick Roy 17/51
2005-06 MM-SC BeeHive, Remarkable Matted Matrials Sidney Crosby 24/50
2005-06 129 The Cup Patch Auto Maxim Lapierre 52/199 1 C Patch
2006-07 170 The Cup Patch Auto Phil Kessel 13/99 Black patch
2006-07 135 The Cup Patch Auto Patrick O'Sullivan 68/249 2 C Patch

So what shuld ido?

This is the Crosby:
http://cgi.ebay.com/ws/eBayISAPI.dll?ViewItem&rd=1&item=370019273779&ssPageName=STRK:MEWA:IT&ih=024

Realy need some quik help!!!
Thanks!
/Jimmy Särås

 

[FASTMAX]

If it were me, not a chance I would give all that up for the Crosby. Maybe if it were 3 clr, but you are giving up some heavy hitters there. But if you absolutly must have the Crosby....



Doug.

 

[Nathan7070]

Seems like alot to give up for one card. Especially those Premier RCs....those aren't exactly small cards. Plus, the other Crosbys and Lundqvist you are adding are nice cards as well.

Maybe its just me but I think you could sell only HALF of those cards and have enough funds to get the Crosby from an ebay auction.

Hope it works out for you either way!

 

[Cujo31]

There is no need of those types of Comments....

 

[gamebreakers]

I believe it's way too much to give up for a 1 color Crosby but like someone said earlier, if you MUST have it...

 

[SMELLTHEVICTORY]

I'm Actually On The "no" Band Wagon.. You Will Be Able To Get Another One For Way Less.. Those Are Diamonds You Have There.. Ya Its A Crosby Cup But I'm Still A No.. Tim..

 

[Särås]

So, could some one else offer me a beter deal?

I realy whant to have the Crosby to my set...
Whats the real value on the Crosby?
Thanks!
/Jimmy Särås

 

[Särås]

By the way, i alredy have copys of every card that are somthing to have in the trade...
I have 2001-02 Premier set, 2002-03 Premier, 2003-04 Premier and soon 2005-06 The Cup...
Wy shuld i have them in dubbles?
Thanks!
/JImmy Särås

 

[gamebreakers]

All that really matters is how YOU feel about the trade. If you're happy with it then do it. It matters little what we think

 

[Särås]

All that really matters is how YOU feel about the trade. If you're happy with it then do it. It matters little what we think

I realy don't know the value on the Crosby becorse i have been thinking that it's to expensive for me... So just been dreaming of it...

So know i could ownit...
Mayby shuld i sell all the cards and looking for a beter patch Crosby to my set?
But then, i need to sell the cards for more and allso fins a Crosby and a seller icould trust!
I have been making some deal before whit the seller, he is nice if You ask me...
But still i feel that all the cards that i give up is some heavy cards and some are just on the way up!
Lookat Lundqvist and Zetterberg in Sweden and it's 2 Crosby cards from RC year in the deal to!

But i realy love the filing to have the Crosby in my set!
What shuld i do?
Take more time and see?
/Jimmy Särås

 

[gamebreakers]

My opinion is that he is winning on the overall deal but in the end you are getting the card YOU want so it's up to you...

 

[Särås]

My opinion is that he is winning on the overall deal but in the end you are getting the card YOU want so it's up to you...

Thats my feeling to!
And in cash in 10 years from now it's a mega great deal for the seller! :/

 

[gamebreakers]

Thats my feeling to!
And in cash in 10 years from now it's a mega great deal for the seller! :/

Maybe. Maybe not. My feeling is if he's attempting to sell the Crosby, he will most likely sell those cards soon to recuperate his money

 

[The Great Zo]

I vote a big "no" to the deal. Whoever is on the other end of that deal would be practically committing theft.

 

[Nathan7070]

I say he makes at least a grand more that what the Crosby would get him from the cards you are offering since he is most likely just going to re-sell them.

I honestly think you could find a nicer patch. Maybe offer a revised deal without that Crosby Ultimate Auto RC or something else.

It just seems like too much to give up but then again there is that old adage that whoever gets the best player in the deal wins and in this case you would be getting the best card.

Its all up to you....good luck

 

[gamebreakers]

I think that everyone will agree that the seller is getting the better deal by far. What he's trying to figure out is whether or not he can find one in a better trade. That I'm not so sure of.

 

[Särås]

I think that everyone will agree that the seller is getting the better deal by far. What he's trying to figure out is whether or not he can find one in a better trade. That I'm not so sure of.

And if im selling all cards and every deal on them going my way whats the best $$$$ my cards could bring on Ebay?

Let say it's like $7-9k?
Or?
Tell me some one...Think my head have been crazy now!
Best regards
/Jimmy

 

[leafschik1967]

Yes, you are giving up a lot, but in order to get anyone to trade down on a Crosby Cup RC, no matter what the patch looks like, you are probably going to have to eat something somewhere.

Your other (maybe better) option is to sell those cards, and keep an eye out for someone selling a Crosby Cup RC, you can probably strike a better deal for yourself with cash in hand. If you are dead-set on trading, though - I'm not sure you'll do much better.

 

[Särås]

So every one is more no then yes?
/J

 

[TBstanleycup04]

I think we've all just about said no !
But not my cards anyways..
Pete