I was looking at one today.
Overall, I like them, the west all star anyway.
The downside, the crest, is hardly a crest, it's like a vinyl decal that's stitched onto the jersey, unlike old crests, looks and more importantly feels cheap.
I really like the colouring on the west, and I am heavily considering buying a smyth, cept the focker is going to wear #93 (why the hell he's giving perreault 94 is beyond me, smyth is by far the better player, and perreault is only there because every team has to be represented.)
But aside from the crest, they aren't that bad.
I'm interested to see the regular jersey's though, all star jersey's have always been a bit gimicky with the design/etc so I'll pass judgement when the regular jersey's are unveiled.