NHL Debuts 2011-12

[The Great Zo]

Just getting caught up on this thread after a few weeks away. A few thoughts and questions:

B) someone who got a UD card but not a Panini card, perhaps one of the SPA guys or something that Panini expected to slip through the cracks but UD got them into something.

This doesn't settle it completely, but I note that the six "first RCs in SPA" listed by Jon all have cards in Rookie Anthology. Jon also notes that every eligible 11-12 rookie player has earned a RC (plus Warren Peters), and Rookie Anthology is pretty much loaded. About the only thing left to do is compare Jon's master 11-12 list with the Rookie Anthology checklist, and I feel too lazy to do that tonight .

Question 1: I am 90% sure the answer is no, but, are there any rookie players in Titanium who do not have RCs in other products?

Question 2: Are the "Rookie Treasures" #/499, #/199, and #/99 cards considered part of the base set of Rookie Anthology -- and thus true RCs?

Question 3: Maybe this one is fishing for opinions, but are the Luxury Suite rookies bound to be considered RCs or not? I could see them compared to 10-11 and 11-12 UD Ice, but I could also see them compared to Elite / National Treasures from 10-11 Zenith.

 

[numbern9ne]

Just getting caught up on this thread after a few weeks away. A few thoughts and questions:



This doesn't settle it completely, but I note that the six "first RCs in SPA" listed by Jon all have cards in Rookie Anthology. Jon also notes that every eligible 11-12 rookie player has earned a RC (plus Warren Peters), and Rookie Anthology is pretty much loaded. About the only thing left to do is compare Jon's master 11-12 list with the Rookie Anthology checklist, and I feel too lazy to do that tonight .

Question 1: I am 90% sure the answer is no, but, are there any rookie players in Titanium who do not have RCs in other products?

Question 2: Are the "Rookie Treasures" #/499, #/199, and #/99 cards considered part of the base set of Rookie Anthology -- and thus true RCs?

Question 3: Maybe this one is fishing for opinions, but are the Luxury Suite rookies bound to be considered RCs or not? I could see them compared to 10-11 and 11-12 UD Ice, but I could also see them compared to Elite / National Treasures from 10-11 Zenith.

1. I think you are right with the answer no.
2. I think they are legit RCs
3. Im not considering Ice/LS RCs, but others might have different opinions, I just think they are inserts.