Not Happy with my Redemption Replacement

[njw2013]

Hello

Back in September I purchased a redemption card of Price/Subban Scripted Swatches from 11-12 Cup for 125$ CAD. I asked Upper Deck in December if they were going to produce the card, and they weren't sure. So I asked them to replace the card. And today I got the replacements, and let me tell you im not happy. I got a Price/Mason dual Enshrinements auto from The Cup, and a Kadri/Subban/Cowen SOTT from 10-11 SPA. I believe this is not fair value. I would really appreciate other people's opinion, and if im right or wrong and what I should do. Thx

 

[Superdoup]

As a habs fan, it is disappointing to received other players on your cards but in terms of value, I don't think you are that far off. the triples from SPA are very nice.

 

[SNobles]

I really think the autos are the main part of the cards although the swatches can make a big difference in value. You got the same players but not together and for an MTL fan that could make all of the difference. You got 3 additions signatures although 1 is a Leaf so I am guessing that isn't great, one is a Sens so that might be even worse for you and the other is Mason who isn't getting a lot of hobby love.

If you are not happy let them know for sure and good luck.

 

[gobuffalo2331]

I see your point, you were hoping for one high end card in exchange for your high end card not being replaced. It could be worse, but your replacements weren't great either. I can see UD sending an extra lower end card but that's probably it.

 

[FrozenInferno]

A redemption for a patch card should have a patch replacement, just my opinion.

 

[No No No.....The other Steve]

If you bought a redemption for a card in September from a year old product of a player who hasn't had an auto returned in that time you knew the wait was eminent. Why after only 3 months ask for a replacement? If you are going to be that impatient why buy the redemption in the first place and not wait for a live copy? I don't think the replacements are that far off $$ wise as the triple sells in the $100-110 range on it's own. Sorry but no reason for complaining on this one.

 

[hextall27]

meh, i've had way worse replacements.