opinions needed:

[Bulk-Buyer]

i had:

SHANNON ELIZABETH
2008-09 CHAMP'S HOCKEY CHAMPS MINI SIGNATURES

to be exchanged, i asked for another sp mini from the set, non hockey and received this:

08-09 spx steve mason dual jersey rookie auto /999 as a replacement. jerseys are black.

do you think this is a fair replacement?

thanks.

 

[geschrocks33]

I'm gonna say no, that Shannon Elizabeth would have brought you far more interest than that Mason

 

[bidds55]

I'm gonna say no, that Shannon Elizabeth would have brought you far more interest than that Mason

what he said.

 

[g-force]

I'd also disagree with that swap out Darren. The Mason is getting weaker by the day while the Elizabeth auto would have done well.

 

[shortstopguy12]

heck with the value... which one would you rather look at?

 

[cardz1976]

I would not be happy with that , I think that the Elizabeth would be more sought after.

 

[pharmd30usp]

have to go with no on that one as well.

 

[smekm]

Not even close I would have ask for the Les stroud one

 

[drkicker]

What where people paying for the Elisabeth ? 50$ ? more ?

If it was selling for 50$ or less, i think its fair.The Mason spx probally sold close to 50$ last year while he was on fire, now its selling for 20$ its not UD fault.

The MAson bv is 100, the Elisabeth 100.

 

[Bulk-Buyer]

thanks for the input guys, much appreciated. rather than have the hassle dealing with ud, i guess i will just eat the loss in value.

 

[KabbyKev]

thanks for the input guys, much appreciated. rather than have the hassle dealing with ud, i guess i will just eat the loss in value.

...which is exactly what they hope and want...

I'd be pretty upset with that exchange Darren

 

[hawkeenut]

Tell them you want the Tiger Woods auto, they probably will just give those away now LOL!!!
Im a Mason collector and I wouldn't be happy with that, maybe if it was the patch variation!!

 

[Triple B]

Didn't someone else get a dual auto with Brodeur in exchange for a Shannon Elizabeth auto? Either way, even as a Mason collector, the Shannon Elizabeth auto would have brought more interest than the Mason (which sells for under $30 on the 'bay).