PSA or Beckett grading for vintage cards?

book'emdano

Verified Trader,
Joined
Nov 2, 2011
Messages
828
Reaction score
0
Location
Calgary, AB
I recently traded for some vintage late 60's, early 70's cards and would like to get them graded to preserve them. Almost every one i know does PSA for vintage but a few people prefer Beckett. Which grading service should i use?
 
Vintage = PSA
Newer Product = Beckett

that's kind of the Industry standard...why fight it..others will mostly expect Vintage cards to be graded by PSA and many track their sets on the website..you can't do that if you have mixed brand...spoken by a PSA collector
 
PSA all the way for me, and go with no qualifiers. You will get more for a PSA 7 then you will a PSA 9OC, people, especially set builders, will not buy cards graded with qualifiers.
 
"PSA all the way for me, and go with no qualifiers. You will get more for a PSA 7 then you will a PSA 9OC, people, especially set builders, will not buy cards graded with qualifiers."


What is a qualifier?
 
Qualifiers

OC (Off Center):
When the centering of the card falls below the minimum standard for that grade will be designated "OC." PSA determines centering by comparing the measurements of the borders from left to right and top to bottom. The centering is designated as the percent of difference at the most off-center part of the card. A 5% leeway is given to the front centering minimum standards for cards which grade NM 7 or better. For example, a card that meets all of the other requirements for PSA MINT 9 and measures 60/40 off-center on the front automatically meets the PSA front centering standards for MINT 9. If a card meets all of the other requirements for PSA MINT 9 and measures 65/35 off-center on the front, it may be deemed to meet the PSA front centering standards for MINT 9 if the eye appeal of the card is good.

ST (Staining):
Cards with staining below the minimum standards for the grade will be designated "ST."

PD (Print Defect):
Cards with significant printing defects will be designated "PD."

OF (Out of Focus):
Cards with focus below the minimum standards for the grade will be designated "OF."

MK (Marks):
Cards with writing, ink marks, pencil marks, etc. or evidence of the impression left from the act of writing will be designated "MK."

MC (Miscut):
Cards that exhibit an atypical cut for the issue or ones that contain partial portions of more than one card will be designated "MC."

UNGRADEABLE CARDS:
PSA will not grade cards that bear evidence of trimming, re-coloring, restoration, or any other forms of tampering, or are of questionable authenticity. In addition, PSA does not grade autographed cards dated earlier than 1998 or any cards manufactured by Star except Star Baseball and 1996 Star Topps (reprint) Basketball Cards; only factory imprint signatures can be graded.
 
in addition PSA will not grade cards with stamps affixed to them or booklets that can't be opened..I found out about the Stamp issue the hard way...and when I sent the card back in got dinged with a ST qualifier for the glue resin...doh!
 
Whats the cheapest way to get grading done? Only have around 10-20 I would like to get done. Also, is it worth it to get cards graded that will only grade around a 4? (speaking of 1951 parkhurst etc)
 
Whats the cheapest way to get grading done? Only have around 10-20 I would like to get done. Also, is it worth it to get cards graded that will only grade around a 4? (speaking of 1951 parkhurst etc)

we should do a group thing and maybe get a cheaper rate between a couple of us, I know I have only about 15 that I want to get graded at the moment and the PSA website is a good place to find info
 
we should do a group thing and maybe get a cheaper rate between a couple of us, I know I have only about 15 that I want to get graded at the moment and the PSA website is a good place to find info

Was looking there. It says 17 bucks a card or if your a member, 10 bucks for a group if 10 or more. Is it worth it to become a member? Any members chime in?
 
I am currently working on the 51/52 Parkhurst set. I admit that PSA is better for vintage, basically in every aspect.

However... honestly.. I cant stand the PSA slabs. I dunno why, they just seem flimsy to me. I really like the heavy feel and quality of BVG slabs.

So I go against the masses on this one and only buy BVG.

PSA also will most likely get you a better sale price in the future if you ever decided to let your collection go.

I suppose if you intend to keep the cards forever like I am then just use what ya like.

Chance
 
I am currently working on the 51/52 Parkhurst set. I admit that PSA is better for vintage, basically in every aspect.

However... honestly.. I cant stand the PSA slabs. I dunno why, they just seem flimsy to me. I really like the heavy feel and quality of BVG slabs.

So I go against the masses on this one and only buy BVG.

PSA also will most likely get you a better sale price in the future if you ever decided to let your collection go.

I suppose if you intend to keep the cards forever like I am then just use what ya like.

Chance

I agree with you that PSA holders are so flimsy and cheap looking. I have had a few that I was not impressed with. The cards seem to move around in the holders. BGS holders are built like tanks and look way better in my opinion. That being said vintage sells better in a PSA holder.

I would go with SCG grading service before PSA as well.
 
I agree with Plubers. PSA cards often move around in there holders and can get damaged if they are moved or shaked around too much. Thin and easily breakable holder. Drop one on the floor and see what happens. The BGS holder can take a beating much better. I know they say PSA sells better for vintage, but I would never invest in any high-end vintage that are in PSA holders - too risky.
 
PSA all the way on vintage. The cases stack together really well and take up little room. I love the look of the BGS or BVG cases but I find them big and bulky.
 
we should do a group thing and maybe get a cheaper rate between a couple of us, I know I have only about 15 that I want to get graded at the moment and the PSA website is a good place to find info

often your LCS will organize a group send through the store if you can get enough people..I know the guys in Calgary at Eastridge Hobbies have done a few that way….food for thought
 
OK, I've heard it on here before that PSA is better than BGS for vintage, but can someone explain why?


I am not sure if it is about the grading job done by each company but more about the resale value that comes with what collectors are willing to pay.It seems that collectors put a lot more trust into the job PSA do on the vintage and therefore are willing to pay more. If it was only about the grading job and not about the money on resale.I would not have either one of those companies do cards for me.
 
Thanks for the advice guys! I really wanted to get my collection graded by PSA until today. I did a "shake" test on a PSA graded card and a Beckett graded card. The PSA graded card slid around in its case but the Beckett graded card didn't move at all. I like the vintage style but I think Beckett is more practical. Lmk what you think.
 
Thanks for the advice guys! I really wanted to get my collection graded by PSA until today. I did a "shake" test on a PSA graded card and a Beckett graded card. The PSA graded card slid around in its case but the Beckett graded card didn't move at all. I like the vintage style but I think Beckett is more practical. Lmk what you think.
You are correct! Cases are flimsy, cards shake around in the holders . . . The only reason to have PSA vintage is the resale value. Even if PSA are excellent graders, what's the point when their holders are crap? Go with BGS for the better protection - better in the short-term and long-term.
 

Forum statistics

Threads
389,467
Messages
2,232,811
Members
4,146
Latest member
E_Thom_Tech
Back
Top