Query about redemption offer from Panini

[711ofovertime]

I have a 2010-11 Luxury Suite Gold #131 Jordan Eberle JSY AU RC /10 with Panini. The regular card /199 has a HI Book Value of $150.00.

Panini believes that they have given all ten of these cards away and take no ownership for this as the managers were not employed by Panini before 5 months ago. They cannot find one of these cards anywhere. This is really not my problem as I had one of the ten redemptions....

I understand that I will have to get a replacement. What BV do you think is fair?

Any advice would be helpful.

 

[rvelligan]

Aim high. They screwed up, so you have a right to ask for what you think is fair. I would say triple book of Regular card. Eberle is one of the best rookies from that year.

 

[OT Sports]

I wouldn't bother with giving a bv. just tell them which players you want. from my experience, their replacements are usually more than fair.

 

[MASTERP]

300 or more value wise is my two cents.

 

[mark14h]

tell'em Ebs is a future HOF'er. You need to be compensated.

 

[frankiefives]

BV should be in the $400-$500 range. Whatever you do, be nice. Getting angry with them won't help your cause. These companies usually react better to people who seem understanding rather than pissed off

 

[711ofovertime]

Thanks for the tips everyone. I will approach with all the advice in mind.