Question on this AHL LOGO?!?!?

[shortstopguy12]

I have been offered a 09-10 H&P Jay Bouwmeester 1/1 AHL Logo in a trade. The guy wants $350 CASH Value for it..... does this seem reasonable? I am not too familiar with these Logo cards.... and have no clue as to Bouwmeester's hobby value. Any help would be greatly appreciated

 

[Triple B]

Lesser players have sold for more...if you don't want it, I'll take it

 

[cfind]

Does he have any other AHL logos available? I think that would be an awesome pickup of an established Elite NHL'er.

 

[TanguayFan]

He had it listed on eBay with a reserve, and it didn't break $160.

 

[Triple B]

I think people tend to shy away from reserve auctions...if he had let it go, he may have got his money.

 

[frankiefives]

A Mike Green ended at $300 on the bay. I'd say Green's hobby value is MUCH higher than Bouwmeester's. I'd say $225-$250 cash value would be more the range

 

[cards-gotta-go]

Lorraine bought the Hodgson for $450... judge for yourself.

 

[wildfan1833]

I wont say what I'm willing to pay for the Gillies untill it's offered to me

 

[GabbyGuy]

Does he have any other AHL logos available? I think that would be an awesome pickup of an established Elite NHL'er.

Elite??? Ok....if you think so..... LOL...kidding. He's a good player...but....

All I can say is, I couldn't even sell my Brent Burns AHL Logo card for $120.....so $350 is really a stretch. My opinion....

 

[Kehfee]

I'd say that's high. Then again, if Bouw is someone you collect then it's a nice cornerstone.

 

[geplimestone]

i'd have to agree, $350 is a little high....most commons players do $100-200 and they odd sale for more.....but it's a 1/1 and they are pretty cool cards....pay whatever you think is reasonable



thanks, Geoff

 

[redmile09]

A little high for me. I wouldn't pay more than $250..

 

[leafscollector#1]

i would have to say 200 - 250$ range? 350$ definetly a little high i think

i saw a Tlusty go for 155$ or so about a month ago, so you can definetly expect to pay more than that

 

[spiral8]

Seems a touch high. I remember that I picked up my Seabrook for $200 (however, at the time the CDN$ was weak)

That being said, I don't think the asking price it totally out of line either

 

[holygoalie]

$200.00 to $250.00 as some others have said. The right collector may shell out $350.00 but then the question becomes; Are you the right collector? Good luck with it. If it was trade value I would do it. -Mike :beer: