Should i request a replacement for this panini redemption

[MikeFitz]

So in January I pulled a redemption from limited (surprise! I got 11 out of 8 packs) I have gotten all of them except for two, which I inquired about .

1 Triple auto of the Staal's xx/25
definitely waiting for this one to be made.

2. Banner season signature prime materials Martin St. Louis xx/25

I dont collect St.louis and would only flip this card as soon as I get it. Panini emailed me today and said this:
"You may request after the 4 month wait is over that we send you out a random pulled card of equal value as a trade or continue waiting for the actual card. Please let us know of your decision. Thank you and have a great day!"

So how fair are they with a replacements? It is a patch auto out of 25. Kinda looking for opinions/info.

Mike

 

[paulxing]

request it if you were going to flip it anyway

 

[KabbyKev]

Panini emailed me today

This alone is a huge coup! :giggity:

 

[Bulldog24]

The Staals should be out, I just got Marc's stuff this week.

 

[MikeFitz]

sweet news about the Staal's.

 

[The Germinator]

Ask for a replacement. St-Louis's stuff doesnt sell that high even if he's one of the best in the league. Anyway, you were going to flip it...try your luck

 

[GabbyGuy]

The Staals should be out, I just got Marc's stuff this week.

EDIT: Put this on a Panini Redemption thread instead...