UD Mail / Replacement. How'd I do? So Sid the Kid action.

[87pensfan66]

Hey,

I got a UD replacement for a 14-15 UD Ice Crosby Scripted Swatches. Apparently it was an SSP. After about a year (and seeing other people list theirs online) I asked for a replacement. Here's what they sent:



I'm kinda up in the air about the replacement. The original was an autographed jersey.... What do you think?

Mike

 

[newfiecomicguy1]

I really like the Ice SS but that one is also really nice. I don't think you did badly, it is S nice low number hard signed auto of the games best player :beer: I would be happy with it.

 

[rvelligan]

I would agree. Give me a hard signed auto over a acetate auto any day.

 

[mortuus]

I would agree. Give me a hard signed auto over a acetate auto any day.

that one would also been hard signed, imo he got a worse replacement.

 

[FrozenInferno]

I'd rather have the Ultimate Achievements card. Who knows how the Scripted Swatches would have turned out, it could have been signed over a black jersey piece so you could barely even see the auto. The Ultimate autos are always well designed and have nice signing areas.

 

[dismonkey1]

I personally would prefer the scripted swatches (smudged or not) over just about anything Ultimate. However, the fact that this is also #/25 helps a little. I think in the end it is probably a fair trade. At least you have a nice card in hand vs. waiting forever for a card that might never see the light of day.

 

[wings1908]

You should have asked for a Redwing player for your replacement, but I guess that's okay,Nice card Mike

 

[yzerberg]

i like it as well. thx for sharing!

 

[creasecollector]

I like it ! Very nice !

 

[Price is right31]

Nice card! Can't be wrong with a Sid The Kid on-card auto!