Vintage (pre-war) Professionals - Your Opinions Needed

[MMarch]

Not my auction, but a card I am interested in. Please take a look at this auction, and the questions the seller was asked - http://cgi.ebay.com/ws/eBayISAPI.dl...em=&sspagename=STRK:MEWAX:IT&salenotsupported

What am I missing? SGC does the same as PSA and BVG I Believe and will offer an Authentic grade instead of a numbered grade if requested correct? Both questions asked are challenging the authenticity of the card, not sure I understand why.

 

[Ironman Indy]

I don't know why the person asking the question has a problem with this card or seller.

I would have no problem buying that card and be comfortable with it.

Looks good to me

I still need the Worters but if you are bidding on it I'll wait til the next one

 

[penguinsrock93]

You can ask only for a card to be authenticated and not graded. This way you know you have a genuine copy of the card that hasn't been tampered with.

However, the seller is just as rude as the potential buyers. Geez why are you posting those type of answers in your auctions!

 

[exchefy1]

Could card be authentic but trimmed ?? not sure with SGC but PSA definitely has evid of trimming.. but penguinsrock might be right they just sent it in to make sure it wasn't a reprint..your call I only use PSA..

Darren