What should I do??

[xmitsui]

Hi guys,

Back in 08-09, I redeemed the Doug Gilmour / Theo Fleury dual auto shield and after 3+ years of wait, I was told that the card would not be produced.

UD sent me this card for replacement:
08-09 Guy Lafleur / Frank Mahovlich dual auto shield

The problem is, the shield for Frank Mahovlich was only event used, so I'm not too happy about it and asked UD to provide me with a list for another replacement.

After near six months of negotiations, finally they have come up with a list:

UD Black - Trophy Cuts - Clarence Campbell/Mike Modano 1 of 1

with either: 11/12 Ultimate UDJ-GL Gretzky/Lemieux #/5 OR 10/11 The Cup CE3-CPT Gretzky/Lemieux/Yzerman #/15

What do you guys think?

Thanks in advance!

 

[borcky90]

I think you own the best card of the group to best honest. But I love the trophy cuts from black, they are booklets im pretty sure and sexy cards. Best bet would be the Gretzky/Lemieux if your really that unhappy.

 

[habsheaven]

I'd like to know why the Lafleur/Mahovlich shield is available to be given out as a replacement?

 

[punkoholic]

I'd like to know why the Lafleur/Mahovlich shield is available to be given out as a replacement?

UD is trying to get rid of this card since late April to replace other shield cards they couldn't produce.

I'm assuming it was originally a redemption and when the redemption didn't get redeemed, this card became extra.

Read this thread....

http://www.hobbyinsider.net/forum/showthread.php?t=322831&highlight=jason+kidd

 

[JoelCarry]

Patrick interesting replacement list. Unless you collect Gilmour or Fluery it would come down to value. Myself being a Flower fan would have kept the replacement shield they sent.
Ok so trophy cut plus the dual Gretzky/Lemieux jersey /5 (i think /5 would be the dual patch if i am not mistaken) would be my choice.

On a side note i don't like the trophy cuts and traded mine away. (sticker auto plus cut auto not my cup of tea)

 

[xmitsui]

Joel, I have decided to keep the replacement shields.

Patrick interesting replacement list. Unless you collect Gilmour or Fluery it would come down to value. Myself being a Flower fan would have kept the replacement shield they sent.
Ok so trophy cut plus the dual Gretzky/Lemieux jersey /5 (i think /5 would be the dual patch if i am not mistaken) would be my choice.

On a side note i don't like the trophy cuts and traded mine away. (sticker auto plus cut auto not my cup of tea)

 

[quincy]

Didn't someone else get told SOL on the Modano/Campbell a while back?