I'd post it with a buy it now or the top price and see if you get an offer. I'd consider the price you paid to be regular market. That other lot skewed the market
As for your question, I would say your purchase price is a good starting point. You may be able to get a slight premium now since you knocked the label so that it sits straight in the slab. The crooked label may have hurt the original sale.
As an eBay Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.