Which would you rather have?

H

habscards

Registered Trader,
Joined
Sep 22, 2004
Messages
2,446
Reaction score
0
Location
Kitchener, ON
I have a trade offer right now that I am almost sure about pulling the trigger on. I would just like some people's opinions first. Which is the better package:

-Spezza Prime Genuine Letter /6
-Sawchuk Superlative Franchise complete jersey /9
-Bower/Baun/Horton/Keon/Shack/Sawchuk Superlative Franchise Playoff Contenders Cup Winners six jersey /1 (from 1966-67 the last Leafs Stanley Cup)


or


-Sundin BAP Memorabilia patch /10
-Ward Cup base patch /10
-Gretzky Artifacts patch/tag /5
-Schenn Prime Authentics full tag /3
-Kennedy Superlative Franchise vintage glove /9
-Sundin Superlative jersey /9
-Phaneuf ITG Ultimate emblem /9



Which side would you rather have? All cards would be traders for me so no need to worry about PC.

Thanks for any help.
Jeff
 
This would get my vote:

-Spezza Prime Genuine Letter /6
-Sawchuk Superlative Franchise complete jersey /9
-Bower/Baun/Horton/Keon/Shack/Sawchuk Superlative Franchise Playoff Contenders Cup Winners six jersey /1 (from 1966-67 the last Leafs Stanley Cup)

The Gretzky in package #2 is interesting but not enough for me.
 
Tough call there, but I'd have to go with door #2. Short numbered Gretzky is never a bad thing. Little more diversity in the package as well. Sundin still well collected as well.
 
at first I was thinking #1 hands down but after reading the lists again I think I'd go for #2 with gretzky & bap sundin tipping the scales
 
That 1/1 is a beauty to a Leafs collector I'm sure.. but I'd go with the second package because I'm both a Gretzky/Artifacts homer and that's a sick card. Plus, the authentic TAG of Schenn is a nice piece.
 
Since you stated they would all be traders I would go with door #2.The cards seem like they would be easier to move/sell.
 
I would think that #2 would be easier to trade - so if that's what you're going for.... it's the better package.

Myself, I'd rather own package #1 though: Without the Gretzky, I think I'd rather have the Sawchuk than the entire #2 lot..... and the Cup Winners card is by far the best card listed in either group.
 
30ranfordfan said:
I would think that #2 would be easier to trade - so if that's what you're going for.... it's the better package.

Myself, I'd rather own package #1 though: Without the Gretzky, I think I'd rather have the Sawchuk than the entire #2 lot..... and the Cup Winners card is by far the best card listed in either group.
Click to expand...

At least someone feels like #1 is better, I was begining to think I was all alone on this one. lol
 
Thanks guys for the input. My lot that I have is the second one. I am not doing the trade.

My biggest problem was trading the Gretzky. The six piece would be great but only a select few would be interested in the six jersey 1/1. The Gretzky I will have a lot more amount of people interested in it.

Thanks for the help.
 
re-ac-tor said:
If I was trading for my PC, I would want #1, but as a resale lot I would want #2

My best,

Ken
Click to expand...

That's exactly what I thought for myself for the PC #1 all the way but for trading/resale #2 was the way to go.

I could see myself trading #2 for #1 depending on what the patches and jersey pieces look like. Ex: Is the Gretzky patch a one color or how may 2 color pieces are there on the 6 player. Without pictures it is speculation only, not enough information to say if it was a good trade or not. IMO
 

Latest posts

Forum statistics

Threads
390,203
Messages
2,239,313
Members
4,172
Latest member
Singin
Back
Top