What about a Draft "Cinches & Steals" set. Make it low numbered with patches or emblems. Did all the work for you already
1980 D. Savard 3rd (or Coffey 6th) - Kurri 69th
1981 Hawerchuk 1st - Vanbiesbrouck 72nd
1982 S. Stevens 5th overall - D. Gilmour 134th
1983 Yzerman 4th - Hasek 207th
1984 Lemieux 1st - Robitaille 171st (or B. Hull 117th)
1985 W. Clark 1st - Ranford 52nd
1986 Damphousse 6th - Tugnutt 81st (bad year LOL)
1987 Shanahan 2nd - T. Fleury 166th
1988 Modano 1st - Recchi 67th
1989 Sundin 1st - Bure 113th
1990 Jagr 5th - Bondra 156th
1991 Lindros 1st - Osgood 54th
1992 Yashin 2nd (or Gonchar 11th) - Khabibulin 204th
1993 Kariya 4th - Demitra 227th
1994 R. Smyth 6th - Alfredsson 133rd
1995 Iginla 11th - M. Savard 91st
1996 Briere 24th (yep, best player drafted 24th) (or Phillips 1st) - Chara 56
1997 Thornton 1st - B. Campbell 156th
1998 Lecavalier 1st - Datsyuk 171st
1999 H. Sedin 3rd - Zetterberg 210th
2000 Heatley 2nd - Lundqvist 205th
2001 Kovalchuk 1st - Plekanec 71st (or Sharp 95th or Laich 193rd)
2002 Nash 1st - Keith 54th
2003 Fleury 1st - Halak 271st
2004 Ovechkin 1st - Rinne 258th
2005 Crosby 1st (if not, Price 5th) - Quick 72nd
2006 Toews 3rd - Lucic 50th
2007 Kane 1st - Subban 43rd
2008 Stamkos 1st - Demers 186th